Descartes: The Meditations

Descartes doubts everything he was taught, finds one certainty in his own thinking, and rebuilds God, truth, error and the body from it.

A course on the thought of René Descartes.

Course outline

  1. Tearing Down to the Foundations: The Method of Doubt — Descartes, shaken by Galileo's condemnation, explains why he came to doubt his senses, his waking life and even arithmetic, in search of a foundation nothing could shake.
  2. I Think, I Exist: The One Thing Doubt Cannot Touch — Descartes finds the one sentence no deceiver can make false: each time he thinks 'I am, I exist', it is true, and only a thought, never a bodily act, can carry that proof.
  3. A Thing That Thinks, and the Piece of Wax — Descartes finds that he is a thing that thinks, then melts a piece of wax to show that even bodies are known by the mind, so the mind is known best of all.
  4. The Idea of the Infinite and the God Who Caused It — Descartes finds in his mind one idea too great for a finite thinker to have made, the idea of an infinite being, and argues that God himself must have put it there.
  5. Why I Ever Go Wrong: A Wide Will and a Narrow Understanding — Descartes traces his errors to a will that affirms more than his understanding clearly sees, and finds the cure in holding back judgment.
  6. The Mountain and the Valley: God's Existence, and Why It Makes Knowledge Last — Descartes argues that existence belongs to God's nature as the angles belong to a triangle, answers Gassendi's objection, and shows why only knowing God turns a geometer's proof into knowledge that…
  7. Mind and Body: Two Things, and One Person — Descartes proves that mind and body are two, then admits to Princess Elizabeth that their union is known best by living it, not by thinking it.

Works read in this course

  • Meditations on First Philosophy — Descartes' central 1641 work: six meditations moving from radical doubt (the evil demon) through the cogito to God, the real distinction of mind and body, and the recovery of the external world.
  • Discourse on the Method — Descartes' accessible 1637 intellectual autobiography and statement of method — 'I think, therefore I am' in its first published form.
  • Principles of Philosophy — A 1644 systematic textbook of Descartes' whole philosophy, from metaphysics to physics, written for the schools.
  • The Passions of the Soul — Descartes' late 1649 treatise on the emotions and the union of mind and body — how soul and body interact.
  • Rules for the Direction of the Mind — An early, unfinished work (published posthumously) setting out rules for rightly conducting reason and reaching certainty.
  • Objections and Replies — Published with the Meditations: sets of objections from leading thinkers (Hobbes, Gassendi, Arnauld, Mersenne) with Descartes' detailed replies.

Terms introduced

cogito

Part of the Simposeum course library.