Is Morality Even Real?

Whether moral truth exists: Glaucon's challenge, reason's minimum, then relativism, emotivism and divine command each tested, and the challenge handed on.

A course on the thought of Ethics.

Course outline

  1. The Ring of Gyges — Plato's Glaucon tells the story of a ring that makes its wearer invisible, and argues that people are just only out of fear of being caught.
  2. The Minimum Conception — Through two hard medical cases and Socrates at his trial, the lesson builds the least that every moral theory must accept: act on the best reasons, and count everyone equally.
  3. When in Rome — Cultures disagree about right and wrong, but that tells us what people believe, not whether moral truth exists, even though many customs really are only customs.
  4. Boo and Hurrah — A.J. Ayer argues that a moral sentence states no fact and only expresses a feeling, and we weigh what his view costs: moral reasoning, and real moral disagreement.
  5. The Piety Question — A man prosecuting his own father forces Socrates' question: is right what God commands, or does God command what is right? Thomas Aquinas answers with a law that reason can read.
  6. Why Be Moral? — With the easy answers cleared away, Glaucon's question comes back sharper: why should moral reasons move someone who could do wrong unseen?

Works read in this course

  • Republic, Book II — Plato's dialogue: Glaucon's challenge and the Ring of Gyges — is justice good in itself, or only for its rewards?
  • Euthyphro — Plato's dialogue: Socrates and a young prosecutor on whether the holy is holy because the gods love it, or loved because it is holy
  • (secondary spine) Rachels, The Elements of Moral Philosophy — the minimum conception; the cases of Baby Theresa, Jodie & Mary, Tracy Latimer; the critiques of relativism, subjectivism, and divine command
  • Ayer, Language, Truth and Logic — the emotivist theory of ethics — moral sentences express feeling and seek to influence, and state no fact
  • Aquinas, Summa Theologica — natural law as the alternative to divine command — morality as a rational order reason can read

Terms introduced

the Ring of Gyges, the minimum conception of morality, cultural relativism, impartiality

Part of the Simposeum course library.