Virtue & the Good Life

Aristotle on the final end, the mean and weakness of will; the Stoics' inner freedom; then luck, and whether virtue is enough.

A course on the thought of Ethics.

Course outline

  1. The Final End — Aristotle follows every pursuit up a chain of wanting one thing for the sake of another until it stops at happiness, and then says what happiness is.
  2. The Golden Mean — Aristotle argues that virtue is a settled state of character built by practice, aimed at the right amount for each person, and that some acts have no right amount at all.
  3. Weakness of the Will — Against Socrates, Aristotle argues that a person can know the better and do the worse, and he ranks the self-controlled person, who wins that fight, below the good person, who has no fight at all.
  4. The Stoic Fortress — Epictetus divides everything into what is in our power and what is not, and Marcus Aurelius turns that division into a citadel of the mind.
  5. Does Goodness Need Luck? — Aristotle grants that great misfortune can keep a good person from the fullest happiness, Epictetus denies that anything outside the will can harm a good person, and the lesson weighs what each…
  6. Is Virtue Enough? — Rachels argues that a list of virtues cannot settle hard cases or virtues in conflict; Aristotle answers that practical wisdom sees what the particular case needs, a real answer that still leaves…

Works read in this course

  • Nicomachean Ethics — Aristotle's lectures on the good life: eudaimonia, the function argument, virtue as the mean, habituation, practical wisdom, weakness of will, and the role of fortune and friendship
  • Epictetus, Enchiridion — the Stoic handbook: the dichotomy of control and the invulnerability of the good will
  • Marcus Aurelius, Meditations — the emperor's private Stoic exercises: the indifferents, the discipline of assent, life in accordance with nature
  • (secondary spine) Rachels, The Elements of Moral Philosophy — virtue ethics stated and assessed; its advantages over rule-based theory; the problem of incompleteness

Part of the Simposeum course library.