Sentiment & Utility

Hume and Smith ground morality in feeling, Bentham and Mill measure it by happiness, Sidgwick finds reason divided over whose happiness counts.

A course on the thought of Ethics.

Course outline

  1. Feeling and Happiness: The Tradition's Wager — From Hume's Treatise of 1739 to Mill's Utilitarianism: moral verdicts rest on feeling, happiness is their measure, and the later writers turn from the feeling to the measure.
  2. Hume: Reason, Passion and the Missing Ought — David Hume argues that reason finds facts and tendencies but cannot move us or make an act wrong, so the vice lies in a feeling and no ought follows from an is alone.
  3. Smith: Sympathy and the Impartial Spectator — Adam Smith explains how we feel for others by imagining ourselves in their place, and how an imagined fair onlooker within lets us judge ourselves against our own self-love.
  4. Bentham: The Principle of Utility — Jeremy Bentham makes pleasure and pain the only goods and evils, counts a community as the sum of its members, and so asks of every creature not whether it can reason but whether it can suffer.
  5. Mill's Higher Pleasures and the Objections to Counting — Mill ranks pleasures by the verdict of those who know both and argues that happiness is the end, then faces the framed innocent, the betrayed friend and the endless demand.
  6. Sidgwick's Two Axioms and the Dualism of Practical Reason — Henry Sidgwick finds two principles with reason behind them, care for one's own good and equal care for everyone's, and admits he cannot prove they always agree.

Works read in this course

  • Hume, Treatise of Human Nature & Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals — sentiment as the ground of morals; the is/ought gap; reason the slave of the passions; the sensible knave
  • Smith, The Theory of Moral Sentiments — sympathy and the impartial spectator; the man of humanity and the earthquake in China
  • Bentham, Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation — the principle of utility; the felicific calculus; 'the question is not, Can they reason? but, Can they suffer?'
  • Utilitarianism — Mill's defense: higher and lower pleasures, the competent judge, the proof of the principle, and the place of justice
  • Sidgwick, The Methods of Ethics — the rigorous grounding of utilitarianism on self-evident axioms — and the dualism of practical reason it could not close

Terms introduced

sympathy, the impartial spectator

Part of the Simposeum course library.