The Moral Law

Where morality's authority comes from: Kant's law of reason, its hardest case, Anscombe's charge against it, and the contract that answers differently.

A course on the thought of Ethics.

Course outline

  1. The Only Good Thing: the Good Will — Kant argues that only a good will is good without qualification, and that an act has moral worth when it is done from duty rather than from inclination or for its results.
  2. The Categorical Imperative — Kant separates the ought that serves a want from the ought that binds whatever you want, and gives a test: could your rule be everyone's law without undoing itself?
  3. Persons as Ends — Kant argues that a person has dignity rather than a price, so no one may be used merely as a means, not even to save many others.
  4. The Murderer at the Door — Kant refuses to lie even to a murderer hunting a friend, and a reply keeps his demand that reasons hold for everyone while letting the rule against lying have exceptions.
  5. Was Hiroshima Murder? — Elizabeth Anscombe argues that the bombing of Hiroshima was murder, and that the modern moral 'ought' is a law that has lost its lawgiver.
  6. The Contract — Hobbes grounds morality in the rules frightened, self-interested people need to escape a war of all against all, and Rawls turns the contract into a test: the rules you would choose without knowing…

Works read in this course

  • Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals — Kant's 1785 foundation of ethics: the good will, duty, the categorical imperative and its formulas, autonomy and the kingdom of ends
  • 'On a Supposed Right to Lie from Philanthropy' — Kant's notorious 1797 essay: one may not lie even to a murderer asking where his intended victim has fled
  • Anscombe, 'Modern Moral Philosophy' (1958) — the charge that the modern 'moral ought' is a law without a lawgiver, and the call to return to Aristotle and virtue
  • Anscombe, 'Mr Truman's Degree' (1956) — the protest against honoring Truman: the deliberate killing of the innocent as murder, whatever the consequences
  • (secondary spine) Rachels, The Elements of Moral Philosophy — the categorical imperative and Kant's arguments on lying (ch. 9); respect for persons and Kantian dignity (ch. 10)

Terms introduced

the good will, duty, maxim, the categorical imperative

Part of the Simposeum course library.