The Moral Law
Where morality's authority comes from: Kant's law of reason, its hardest case, Anscombe's charge against it, and the contract that answers differently.
A course on the thought of Ethics.
Course outline
- The Only Good Thing: the Good Will — Kant argues that only a good will is good without qualification, and that an act has moral worth when it is done from duty rather than from inclination or for its results.
- The Categorical Imperative — Kant separates the ought that serves a want from the ought that binds whatever you want, and gives a test: could your rule be everyone's law without undoing itself?
- Persons as Ends — Kant argues that a person has dignity rather than a price, so no one may be used merely as a means, not even to save many others.
- The Murderer at the Door — Kant refuses to lie even to a murderer hunting a friend, and a reply keeps his demand that reasons hold for everyone while letting the rule against lying have exceptions.
- Was Hiroshima Murder? — Elizabeth Anscombe argues that the bombing of Hiroshima was murder, and that the modern moral 'ought' is a law that has lost its lawgiver.
- The Contract — Hobbes grounds morality in the rules frightened, self-interested people need to escape a war of all against all, and Rawls turns the contract into a test: the rules you would choose without knowing…
Works read in this course
- Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals — Kant's 1785 foundation of ethics: the good will, duty, the categorical imperative and its formulas, autonomy and the kingdom of ends
- 'On a Supposed Right to Lie from Philanthropy' — Kant's notorious 1797 essay: one may not lie even to a murderer asking where his intended victim has fled
- Anscombe, 'Modern Moral Philosophy' (1958) — the charge that the modern 'moral ought' is a law without a lawgiver, and the call to return to Aristotle and virtue
- Anscombe, 'Mr Truman's Degree' (1956) — the protest against honoring Truman: the deliberate killing of the innocent as murder, whatever the consequences
- (secondary spine) Rachels, The Elements of Moral Philosophy — the categorical imperative and Kant's arguments on lying (ch. 9); respect for persons and Kantian dignity (ch. 10)
Terms introduced
the good will, duty, maxim, the categorical imperative
Part of the Simposeum course library.