The Reckoning

Nietzsche questions what morality is worth, Foot and Williams test the theories on hard cases, MacIntyre diagnoses the debate, and four exits remain open.

A course on the thought of Ethics.

Course outline

  1. After the Battle: Asking What Morality Is Worth — Before weighing any moral theory, we hear Friedrich Nietzsche ask what morality itself is worth, and learn why that question is a call to value on purpose rather than a licence to do as we like.
  2. The Genealogy: Master Morality and Slave Morality — Nietzsche traces 'good and evil' to the resentment of the weak, presses the charge against pity itself, and still refuses the conclusion that anything goes.
  3. The Trolley: Doing and Allowing — Philippa Foot sets a runaway tram beside a judge who could frame one man to save five, and shows that the line between harming someone and failing to help them explains both verdicts, which neither…
  4. One Thought Too Many: Integrity — Bernard Williams argues that a morality which treats your own projects as one entry in everyone's sum cannot make sense of integrity, and that Kantian impartiality is wounded too.
  5. After Virtue: Why the Argument Never Ends — Alasdair MacIntyre explains why modern moral arguments never end, traces the cause to the broken pieces of an older moral scheme, and narrows our choice to Nietzsche or the tradition of Aristotle.
  6. Living Without the Answer — Four honest ways of living survive the reckoning, none of them wins, and Glaucon's ring comes back to the reader.

Works read in this course

  • On the Genealogy of Morals — Nietzsche's 1887 'polemic': master vs slave morality, ressentiment, the slave revolt in morals, and the demand that the VALUE of our values be, for the first time, called into question
  • Beyond Good and Evil — Nietzsche's 1886 attack on the dogmatists and the 'herd,' and the case that our morality is one type among possible types, not the moral fact itself
  • Foot, 'The Problem of Abortion and the Doctrine of the Double Effect' (1967) — the paper that launched the trolley problem, and the defense of doing/allowing and double effect against a pure calculus of outcomes
  • Foot, Natural Goodness (2001) — Foot's mature return to objective ethics: goodness in a human being as a species of natural goodness, grounded in the human form of life — Anscombe's call answered
  • Williams, 'A Critique of Utilitarianism' (1973) — Jim and the Indians, George and the weapons lab, and the integrity objection to utilitarian impartiality
  • Williams, 'Persons, Character and Morality' (1976) — ground projects, and the drowning-wife case in which a moral justification for saving her is 'one thought too many' — collected in Moral Luck (1981)
  • Williams, Ethics and the Limits of Philosophy (1985) — morality as a 'peculiar institution' — a narrowed, obligation-bound successor to ethics — and the suspicion of ethical theory itself
  • MacIntyre, After Virtue (1981) — the interminability of modern moral debate, emotivism as its truth, the failure of the Enlightenment project, and the return to the Aristotelian tradition of the virtues
  • (secondary spine) Rachels, The Elements of Moral Philosophy — the ethics of virtue and its relation to right-action theories (ch. 12); what a fully satisfactory moral theory would look like (ch. 13)

Terms introduced

genealogy of morals, ressentiment, emotivism

Part of the Simposeum course library.