The Ground
Kierkegaard and Dostoevsky on the weight of being free: anxiety, the underground, Abraham's faith, the Inquisitor's bargain, despair, and what came after.
A course on the thought of Kierkegaard & Dostoevsky.
Course outline
- Anxiety: The Dizziness of Freedom — Kierkegaard argues that a self is made by choosing, and that anxiety is what it feels like to stand before your own possibility before anything has happened.
- The Underground Man: Consciousness Against Action — Dostoevsky's underground man sees so much that he cannot act, and would rather suffer than be a key on somebody's piano.
- Abraham: Faith Above the Ethical — Kierkegaard argues that Abraham on Mount Moriah is either a murderer or a believer, because faith, unlike a tragic hero's sacrifice, puts one person above the rule that binds everyone, and the lesson…
- The Grand Inquisitor: Bread Against Freedom — In a poem told by Ivan Karamazov, an old churchman argues that people would rather be fed and ruled than free, and that Christ asked too much of them.
- The Sickness Unto Death: Despair as Failing to Be Yourself — Kierkegaard argues that despair is not a mood but failing to be the self you are, and that its commonest form is the despair that does not know itself.
- What They Handed Forward — Ivan's returned ticket, Zosima's answer and Kierkegaard's charge against a faith nobody chooses: what the two men left to the people after them.
Works read in this course
- The Concept of Anxiety — Kierkegaard (as Vigilius Haufniensis), 1844 — anxiety as the dizziness of possibility
- Fear and Trembling — Kierkegaard (as Johannes de Silentio), 1843 — Abraham, the leap, and whether a duty can override the ethical
- The Sickness Unto Death — Kierkegaard (as Anti-Climacus), 1849 — despair as a misrelation in the self
- Notes from Underground — Dostoevsky, 1864 — the clerk in the basement who will not be a piano key
- The Brothers Karamazov — Dostoevsky, 1880 — Ivan's poem of the Grand Inquisitor, and the strongest case against his own faith
Terms introduced
the leap, by virtue of the absurd, despair, the underground
Part of the Simposeum course library.