Hegel: Scholar

Hegel's attempt to make radical freedom at home in the world, tested through Spirit, dialectic, the state, the Terror and history's verdict.

A course on the thought of G. W. F. Hegel.

Course outline

  1. Two Ideals at War: Freedom and Belonging — Hegel names the hunger of his age, sets out the two ideals his generation tried to join, and explains why he meant to join them by reason: freedom is being at home with oneself in something outside…
  2. Spirit and Contradiction — Hegel explains why truth is a living whole that grows through loss, why nothing finite stands alone, and why Charles Taylor called the God of this picture a Munchausen God.
  3. Two Kinds of Proof: The Now and the Master — Hegel sets the stale note 'now is night' beside the fight of master and servant, and asks why an argument anyone can test claims more force than a story that persuades only by its fit.
  4. Ethical Life: Freedom Already in the World — Hegel argues that freedom is not a private possession but lives in a shared way of life, and that the state is a living body whose members are not its tools.
  5. Absolute Freedom and the Terror — Why a freedom that will accept no structure it did not make can only destroy, and why Hegel's diagnosis has outlived his remedy.
  6. Reason in History, and What It Left Out — Hegel reads history as the growing knowledge of freedom, carried forward by human passion, and then faces the same lectures' exclusion of Africa from that history.
  7. After Hegel: The Rabble, Marx and Freedom Without a Place — Hegel finds a poverty his civil society cannot cure, Marx moves his scheme from spirit onto human beings, and Taylor explains why Hegel's answers died while his question about where freedom stands…

Works read in this course

  • Phenomenology of Spirit — My 1807 'voyage of discovery' — consciousness educated, shape by shape, from bare sense-certainty to absolute knowing; finished the night before the battle of Jena.
  • Science of Logic — The system's foundation (1812-16) — pure thought deriving its own categories from a beginning with nothing presupposed.
  • Encyclopaedia of the Philosophical Sciences — My complete system in outline (1817; revised 1827, 1830): logic, nature, spirit.
  • Elements of the Philosophy of Right — My political philosophy (1821) — freedom made actual in right, morality, and ethical life.
  • Lectures on the Philosophy of World History — The Berlin lectures (1822-31) — world history as the progress of the consciousness of freedom; the editions are themselves a scholarly battleground.
  • System of Ethical Life — My 1802-03 Jena manuscript — where the struggle for recognition first drives ethical life; Honneth's favorite text.
  • Jena Lectures on the Philosophy of Spirit — The 1805-06 Realphilosophie — labor, language, love, and recognition before the Phenomenology froze them into shapes.
  • Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion — The Berlin lectures — religion and philosophy share one content; the estate my left and right heirs fought over first.

Part of the Simposeum course library.