Heidegger: The Question
What Heidegger's Black Notebooks say about Jews, how the anti-Semitism grew from his story of being, and how far it reaches.
A course on the thought of Martin Heidegger.
Course outline
- The Black Notebooks and the Question They Force — Heidegger lays out what the Black Notebooks are, and why their standing as worked writing kept back for last turns the question from prejudice to thought.
- The Story of Being — After Being and Time, Heidegger told the history of the West as one story: a Greek first beginning, an end in machination and a hoped-for other beginning. The story handed whole peoples their parts.
- Inner Truth and Greatness — Heidegger lays out how one sentence of praise from his 1935 lecture course came to print in 1953, how he defended it then and in 1968, and what that defense asks of the reader.
- Three Kinds of Anti-Semitism in the Notebooks — Following Peter Trawny, Heidegger lays out the three kinds of anti-Semitism in his Black Notebooks and shows how each took an old prejudice and gave it a place in his story of being.
- After the Camps: The Bremen Sentence and the Silence — One sentence from a Bremen lecture set the gas chambers beside mechanized farming as the same in essence, and that sentence is nearly all Heidegger ever said in public about the murder of the Jews.
- How Far Does It Reach? — Peter Trawny argues that the anti-Semitic contamination reaches only as far as a war story of the late 1930s, and Heidegger sets his own words on danger and errancy beside that limit for the reader…
Works read in this course
- The Black Notebooks (Ponderings and Remarks) — Heidegger's private philosophical notebooks, 1931 onward (published from 2014). The Ponderings of 1938-41 (GA95-96) contain the being-historical antisemitism; he ordered them published last, as the capstone of his collected works.
- The Self-Assertion of the German University — The rectoral address of May 1933, Heidegger's inaugural speech as rector of Freiburg — the public face of his Nazi engagement.
- Introduction to Metaphysics — The 1935 lecture course, with its line about the 'inner truth and greatness' of National Socialism — and the bracketed clause whose date became a scandal.
- Bremen Lectures — The 1949 lectures on technology, including the sentence equating mechanized agriculture with the manufacture of corpses in the extermination camps.
- 'Only a God Can Save Us' — The 1966 Der Spiegel interview, published at his death in 1976 — his fullest and most evasive postwar self-account.
- Trawny, Heidegger and the Myth of a Jewish World Conspiracy — The scholarly study (2014) that named 'being-historical antisemitism' and framed the question of contamination this course follows.
Part of the Simposeum course library.