Hume: The Science of Man

How Hume tested every idea against experience, and found cause, self and morals resting on custom and feeling, not reason.

A course on the thought of David Hume.

Course outline

  1. A Science Built on Experience — Hume sets out to study the mind by experience alone, and draws from it a test: every idea is a fainter copy of an earlier impression.
  2. The Billiard Table — At a billiard table Hume finds touch, sequence and constant conjunction but no visible power, and traces the necessity we feel to custom in the watcher's own mind.
  3. Custom Is the Guide — No argument shows that the future will resemble the past; custom carries the mind from what it sees to what usually follows, and belief is the firmer feeling that results, in a dog as in a traveller.
  4. No Self to Find — Hume looks inward for a lasting self, finds only passing perceptions, explains why we call the mind one thing anyway, and admits in print that he could not finish the account.
  5. Reason, the Slave — Hume argues that reason only serves the passions, and that right and wrong are therefore felt from a common point of view rather than discovered by argument.
  6. Miracles and Design — Hume weighs reports of miracles against the whole of experience, then turns the same rule on the argument that the world's order proves a perfect maker.
  7. Nature Is Too Strong — Hume turns his own rule on his doubts about the senses and reason, finds them unanswerable, and shows why nature will not let anyone live by them.

Works read in this course

  • A Treatise of Human Nature — 1739-40, written in his twenties; the full system, including the self and the is/ought passage
  • An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding — 1748; the causation and induction arguments rewritten for readers, plus the essays on miracles and providence
  • An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals — 1751; the moral philosophy restated — Hume thought it his best work
  • Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion — written early, withheld for decades, published posthumously in 1779; the design argument taken apart by Philo
  • Essays, Moral, Political and Literary — the public-facing Hume — including 'Of National Characters' and its notorious footnote
  • My Own Life — the short autobiography written months before his death
  • (secondary, authoring-only) The Cambridge Companion to Hume (2009) — the scholarly frame this course is built on — not ingested, not quoted

Terms introduced

impression, idea, matter of fact, constant conjunction, necessary connexion, custom, the bundle

Part of the Simposeum course library.