William James: The Will to Believe

William James on believing before the proof: freedom, Clifford's rule, self-making faith, truth in the making, and the religious More.

A course on the thought of William James.

Psychology

Course outline

  1. The First Act of Freedom — William James offers no proof that the will is free, shows that regret already assumes the world had real alternatives, and argues that our first free act may rightly be to believe we are free.
  2. The Craving for Rationality — Theory can sort the world but never explain why there is a world, so in the end a philosophy is judged by whether it answers our power to act and the temperament that chose it.
  3. Clifford's Rule and the Genuine Option — James sets Clifford's rule against belief without evidence beside his own case for a genuine option, and a later critic asks whether he treated Clifford fairly.
  4. Faith That Helps Create Its Fact — Some facts cannot arrive unless we first trust that they will, and James argues that believing life is worth living is one of them.
  5. Truth Happens to an Idea — James argues that truth is not a fixed copy of reality but something an idea becomes as it leads us well through experience, and then faces Royce's objection about truths of the past.
  6. The Sick Soul and the Second Birth — James argues that the sick soul, who counts evil as a real part of the world, sees more of life than the cheerful once-born, and finds peace only when a divided self is made whole.
  7. Mystical States and the More — James breathes nitrous oxide, defines the mystical state, rules that it binds only the one who has it, and names the MORE behind it as his own over-belief.

Works read in this course

  • The Will to Believe (1897) — my essays in popular philosophy — the title essay on the right of the passional nature to decide genuine options, with 'Is Life Worth Living?' beside it.
  • Talks to Teachers on Psychology (1899) — the teacher lectures, with the Talks to Students appended — 'On a Certain Blindness in Human Beings' and 'What Makes a Life Significant' are there.
  • The Varieties of Religious Experience (1902) — my Gifford Lectures at Edinburgh — religion studied in its documents, the personal experience of the divided and the devout, from the healthy-minded through conversion to mysticism.
  • The Principles of Psychology (1890) — the psychology this tier builds on — the perception of reality chapter is its hinge into belief.
  • The Letters of William James (1920) — my correspondence and diaries — the crisis of 1870 and the faith experiments are recorded there in my own hand.

Terms introduced

genuine option, the sick soul, the MORE

Part of the Simposeum course library.