Marx & Engels: Scholar

Six contested questions about Marx and Engels: dialectics, dictatorship, the young Marx, historical law, the family, science, argued from their own texts.

A course on the thought of Karl Marx & Friedrich Engels.

Course outline

  1. The Invention of Dialectics: Did Engels Distort Marx? — Engels made dialectics a set of laws running through nature, society and thought; Marx used it for how societies change and how Capital is laid out, and Terrell Carver argues the wider step was…
  2. The Dictatorship of the Proletariat: Democracy or Despotism? — Marx defined the dictatorship of the proletariat only as a passage to a classless society, and his one model, the Paris Commune, was elected, recallable and paid workers' wages, which leaves the…
  3. Young Marx and Mature Marx: Is There a Break? — Marx's 1844 pages on estranged labour sit beside a passage from Capital, and the reader weighs whether one ripening argument or two different projects lies between them, a question that exists only…
  4. Iron Laws or Agency: Does History Decide Us? — Marx's 1859 Preface sounds like an iron law of history, but his account of Louis Bonaparte's coup and Engels's late letters show people making history in circumstances they did not choose, with the…
  5. Engels on the Family: Foundational or Flawed? — Engels ties women's subjection to private property and inheritance; much of the anthropology he took from Morgan is shaky, but his claim that unequal laws grow from economic dependence can be weighed…
  6. Greatness or Illusion: Was Any of It Science? — Engels called Marx the Darwin of history; Marx asked of a science only that facts replace dogmas, and the reader decides whether either earns the word.

Works read in this course

  • Anti-Dühring — Engels' 1878 polemic — the most systematic statement of 'dialectical materialism,' extending the dialectic to nature and science.
  • Dialectics of Nature — Engels' unfinished notebooks (1883) applying dialectical laws to the natural sciences — the heart of the 'did Engels distort Marx?' debate.
  • Theses on Feuerbach — Marx's eleven terse 1845 theses — including 'the philosophers have only interpreted the world; the point is to change it.'
  • The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte — Marx's 1852 study of the 1851 coup — the great statement that men make history, but not in conditions of their choosing.
  • A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy — Marx's 1859 work; its Preface gives the sharpest 'determinist' statement of the materialist conception of history.
  • The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State — Engels' 1884 materialist history of the family — a founding text of socialist feminism, and a contested one.

Part of the Simposeum course library.