What There Is

Five philosophers argue over what exists: things and their qualities, the forms they share, wholes and their parts, and kinds of being.

A course on the thought of Metaphysics.

Course outline

  1. The Question Itself: Being as Being — Metaphysics asks what is really there behind how things seem, and Aristotle named a single study of being as being, first philosophy, because every other science takes only one slice of what is.
  2. A Thing and Its Qualities — Everything we perceive in a thing is a quality, and John Locke argues that we suppose something underneath to hold those qualities while having no clear idea of what it is.
  3. Substratum or Bundle — David Hume looks for the impression behind the idea of substance and finds none, so a thing becomes a collection of qualities; Locke answers that qualities cannot belong to nothing, and each side…
  4. The One Over the Many — Many things share one thing that is none of them. In his Parmenides, Plato proposes a separate Form that they partake of, and then shows that this Form seems to call up an endless series of further…
  5. Universals in Things — Aristotle keeps the universal but moves it into particular things, so that the single horse or man, not a Form above it, is what is most fully real.
  6. Only Particulars: Quine's Test — W. V. O. Quine offers a test for what a theory says there is, frees red houses from any need for redness, and leaves the nominalist a bill of sentences to rewrite.
  7. Wholes and Their Parts — Aristotle uses a syllable and a house to show that a whole is its matter made one by a form, and that answer lets a thing keep its identity while its parts change.
  8. The Table of Being — Aristotle sorts everything we can say of a thing into ten kinds and argues that substance comes first, since a size or a colour exists only as the way some individual thing is.

Works read in this course

  • Categories — the ten kinds of being; primary substance vs the rest
  • Metaphysics — first philosophy: being qua being, substance, form & matter, the whole
  • Physics — nature, the this-something, matter and form in change
  • Plato, Republic & Phaedo — the theory of separate Forms, presented and contested
  • Hume, Treatise I; Locke, Essay II — the bundle / substratum debate, brought forward
  • Quine, 'On What There Is' — the nominalist's economy of being

Terms introduced

metaphysics, substratum, universal, particular, nominalism, category

Part of the Simposeum course library.