Change, Cause & Time

From Parmenides' changeless being to Lewis's temporal parts: how things change, what a cause is, whether time flows, and how anything lasts.

A course on the thought of Metaphysics.

Course outline

  1. Does Anything Stay the Same? — Parmenides argues that nothing can come to be, Heraclitus that everything is always turning into something else, and between them change itself becomes hard to explain.
  2. Coming to Be Without Contradiction — Aristotle answers Parmenides: nothing comes from sheer nothing, because every change runs from the lack of a form to the form, in something that was there all along.
  3. Four Answers to Why — Aristotle gives four answers to the question why: matter, form, maker and end, and he defends the claim that nature itself works toward ends.
  4. Is There Any Necessary Connection? — David Hume watches one billiard ball strike another, looks for the power that makes the second move, and finds only a regular pairing of events and a habit of expectation in the mind.
  5. Kant Saves the Cause — Immanuel Kant agrees that perception never shows a cause, argues that without a rule of cause we could not tell a real event from a mere run of our own perceptions, and pays for the rescue with a…
  6. Cause as Difference-Making — David Lewis tests a cause by asking what the nearest world without it would be like, and then faces the back-up cause that strains his test.
  7. Does Time Pass? — Henri Bergson defends lived time as a flowing duration that clocks cannot measure, the block view says nothing moves at all, and neither can say how fast time goes.
  8. Surviving Through Time — Two ships, one man learning music and a road between towns show two ways a thing can last through time: Aristotle's whole subject that stays, and David Lewis's parts in time, each with its price.

Works read in this course

  • Heraclitus & Parmenides, the fragments — flux vs the One unchanging being
  • Aristotle, Physics I-II — change via substratum/form/privation; the four causes
  • Hume, Enquiry / Treatise — the critique of necessary connection
  • Kant, Critique of Pure Reason (Second Analogy) — causality as a condition of experience
  • D. Lewis, 'Causation' (1973) — counterfactual analysis of causation
  • Bergson, Time and Free Will / Creative Evolution — lived duration vs spatialized time

Terms introduced

constant conjunction, necessary connection, counterfactual

Part of the Simposeum course library.