Change, Cause & Time
From Parmenides' changeless being to Lewis's temporal parts: how things change, what a cause is, whether time flows, and how anything lasts.
A course on the thought of Metaphysics.
Course outline
- Does Anything Stay the Same? — Parmenides argues that nothing can come to be, Heraclitus that everything is always turning into something else, and between them change itself becomes hard to explain.
- Coming to Be Without Contradiction — Aristotle answers Parmenides: nothing comes from sheer nothing, because every change runs from the lack of a form to the form, in something that was there all along.
- Four Answers to Why — Aristotle gives four answers to the question why: matter, form, maker and end, and he defends the claim that nature itself works toward ends.
- Is There Any Necessary Connection? — David Hume watches one billiard ball strike another, looks for the power that makes the second move, and finds only a regular pairing of events and a habit of expectation in the mind.
- Kant Saves the Cause — Immanuel Kant agrees that perception never shows a cause, argues that without a rule of cause we could not tell a real event from a mere run of our own perceptions, and pays for the rescue with a…
- Cause as Difference-Making — David Lewis tests a cause by asking what the nearest world without it would be like, and then faces the back-up cause that strains his test.
- Does Time Pass? — Henri Bergson defends lived time as a flowing duration that clocks cannot measure, the block view says nothing moves at all, and neither can say how fast time goes.
- Surviving Through Time — Two ships, one man learning music and a road between towns show two ways a thing can last through time: Aristotle's whole subject that stays, and David Lewis's parts in time, each with its price.
Works read in this course
- Heraclitus & Parmenides, the fragments — flux vs the One unchanging being
- Aristotle, Physics I-II — change via substratum/form/privation; the four causes
- Hume, Enquiry / Treatise — the critique of necessary connection
- Kant, Critique of Pure Reason (Second Analogy) — causality as a condition of experience
- D. Lewis, 'Causation' (1973) — counterfactual analysis of causation
- Bergson, Time and Free Will / Creative Evolution — lived duration vs spatialized time
Terms introduced
constant conjunction, necessary connection, counterfactual
Part of the Simposeum course library.