Being, Nothing & God

Why there is anything, what existing means, whether nothing is something, whether reason can prove God, and what Being is.

A course on the thought of Metaphysics.

Course outline

  1. Why Is There Anything at All? — Martin Heidegger calls the question of why there is anything at all the first question of metaphysics, and Peter van Inwagen shows why no ordinary explanation or creation story can answer it.
  2. What Does 'Exists' Mean? — Quine offers a test for what a theory says there is, read off its bound variables, and Carnap answers that choosing those variables is a practical choice of method.
  3. Is Nothing Something? Emptiness — Nāgārjuna argues that nothing has a being of its own, so everything is empty, and that empty is a middle path between solid being and sheer nothing.
  4. That Than Which Nothing Greater — Anselm argues that the greatest conceivable being must exist in reality as well as in thought; Kant replies that existence adds nothing to a concept, and van Inwagen asks whether Kant has found the…
  5. The Reason for the World — Spinoza and Leibniz both hold that everything has a reason, and van Inwagen shows that taking this strictly leaves nothing that could have been otherwise.
  6. God in Modal Dress — Alvin Plantinga recasts Anselm's argument with possible worlds, so that a maximally great being, if it is possible at all, exists in every world, and Peter van Inwagen shows why that possibility…
  7. Being Is Not a Being — Heidegger argues that every proof of a highest being answers with a being, while Being itself is no being at all; van Inwagen replies that being is only self-identity, and the reader weighs the two.

Works read in this course

  • Heidegger, Introduction to Metaphysics / 'What Is Metaphysics?' — the question of Being; the nothing; the ontological difference; onto-theology
  • Quine, 'On What There Is' (1948) — ontological commitment; to be = value of a bound variable
  • Carnap, 'Empiricism, Semantics, and Ontology' (1950) — internal/external questions; metaphysics as pseudo-questions
  • Nagarjuna, Mulamadhyamakakarika — emptiness; dependent origination; the tetralemma on being/non-being
  • Anselm, Proslogion ii-iii — that than which nothing greater can be conceived; existence in re vs in intellectu
  • Kant, Critique of Pure Reason — the refutation of the ontological argument; being is not a real predicate
  • Leibniz, Monadology / Principles of Nature and Grace; Spinoza, Ethics I — the cosmological argument from the PSR; God-or-Nature
  • Plantinga, The Nature of Necessity — the modal ontological argument; necessary being in possible worlds

Terms introduced

the question of Being, ontological commitment, onto-theology

Part of the Simposeum course library.