Freedom, Reality & the Limits of Metaphysics
Nine thinkers on freedom, reality and meaning: from Hume and Sartre on choice to Ayer's attack on metaphysics and Aristotle's answer.
A course on the thought of Metaphysics.
Course outline
- Are We Free? Hume and Kant on Choice and Cause — Hume says you are free whenever you act as you will, even if your will has causes; Kant answers that the word ought needs more, and sees every act twice.
- Condemned to Be Free: Sartre on Existence and Essence — Jean-Paul Sartre argues that a person has no nature given in advance, so we make ourselves by what we do and cannot hide behind our character.
- Is Reality Mind-Dependent? Berkeley and Kant — Berkeley argues that a thing is nothing but the ideas we perceive, held in being by God's mind, and Kant answers that we know only appearances of things that really exist outside us.
- The Absolute: Hegel's Answer to Kant — Hegel answers Kant's limit on knowledge with one step: to know where a limit lies, you must already see past it, so truth is not hidden behind appearances but is the whole of them, worked out to the…
- Is There a Way the World Is? Rorty Against the Mirror — Richard Rorty argues that the picture of the mind as a mirror is optional and that objectivity is agreement won by shared reasons, while the realist replies that a mountain's height owes nothing to…
- Is Metaphysics Even Meaningful? Ayer's Test — A. J. Ayer sorts every sentence into the true-by-definition, the checkable and the empty, and finds metaphysics in the third pile, though his own test would not hold still.
- The Return of Metaphysics: Quine's Web — W.V.O. Quine argues that no clean line divides truths of meaning from truths of fact, because our beliefs meet experience together, and so the question of what there is comes back inside science.
- What Is Metaphysics? Aristotle Has the Last Word — Aristotle names the subject this course has argued over: a science of being as being, begun in wonder and resting on a principle that even its deniers obey.
Works read in this course
- Hume, Enquiry §8 'Of Liberty and Necessity' — compatibilism
- Kant, Critique of Pure Reason (Third Antinomy) / Groundwork — transcendental freedom; acting under the idea of freedom
- Sartre, Being and Nothingness / Existentialism Is a Humanism — radical freedom; bad faith; existence precedes essence
- Berkeley, Principles / Three Dialogues — esse est percipi; immaterialism
- Hegel, Phenomenology / Encyclopaedia Logic — the Absolute; the rational is the real
- Rorty, Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature (1979) — anti-representationalism; no mirror of nature; pragmatist anti-realism
- Ayer, Language, Truth and Logic (1936) — the verification principle; the elimination of metaphysics
- Quine, 'Two Dogmas of Empiricism' (1951) — the fall of analytic/synthetic; the web of belief; metaphysics rehabilitated
Terms introduced
determinism, idealism, the Absolute, verification principle
Part of the Simposeum course library.