Piaget: Scholar

Piaget's account of how children build their world, from egocentrism to formal thought, tested against Donaldson's rival experiments.

A course on the thought of Jean Piaget.

Psychology

Course outline

  1. Talking to No One: What Egocentrism Meant — Two six-year-olds at the Maison des Petits show what Piaget meant by ego-centrism: not selfishness, but failing to see that your point of view is only yours.
  2. Two Points of View at Once: The Brother and the Policeman — Piaget held that a word like brother needs two points of view at once, which the young child lacks; Hughes's hiding game shows three-year-olds taking a policeman's view, and the lesson weighs how far…
  3. The Toy Under the Cloth: Building the Permanent Object — Piaget traces how an infant builds the permanent object through six stages of action, then weighs Bower and Wishart's finding that babies reach for a toy in the dark.
  4. More Red Flowers, or More Flowers? Classes and the Question Asked — Piaget's account of why young children say there are more red flowers than flowers, set against McGarrigle's sleeping cows, which show that the wording of a question moves the answer.
  5. Reversibility, Conservation and the Naughty Teddy — Piaget explains conservation as a deduction from reversible thought, then weighs McGarrigle's Naughty Teddy experiment, which raised conservation sharply though about half the children still failed.
  6. On the Plane of the Possible: Formal Thought and Human Sense — Piaget dated formal thought to eleven or twelve; Donaldson showed that adults fail it too unless the task makes human sense, and that school demands it without teaching it.
  7. What Survives: Construction, Assimilation and the Use of Error — Piaget sets out the claim beneath all his tasks, that a child builds knowledge by taking the world into his schemas and reshaping them where it resists, and weighs it against Donaldson's view of how…

Works read in this course

  • Genetic Epistemology (1970) — my statement of the guiding question — how knowledge is constructed — which the core-knowledge debate directly contests.
  • Baillargeon et al., 'Object permanence in five-month-old infants' (1985) — the violation-of-expectation studies that found object knowledge months before my search test did.
  • Donaldson, Children's Minds (1978) — Margaret Donaldson's landmark case that my tasks underestimated children by ignoring the human sense a child makes of them; reports Hughes's policeman study.
  • McGarrigle & Donaldson, 'Conservation accidents' (1974) — the naughty-teddy study — accidental transformation quadrupled conservation.
  • Vygotsky, Mind in Society (1978) — the social-cultural alternative — the zone of proximal development and learning leading development.

Part of the Simposeum course library.