Why Obey?

Why obey the state? Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau, two anarchists, Hume, Bentham, Rawls and Nozick answer, and each answer is tested.

A course on the thought of Political Philosophy.

Course outline

  1. Why Obedience Is a Question — Laws are made by people, not found in nature, so obeying them is a real question, and calling the existing order natural is already one answer to it.
  2. Hobbes: The War of All Against All — Thomas Hobbes argues that rough equality and distrust turn life without a common power into a war, and that only a sovereign's sword can make promises safe to keep.
  3. Locke: Everyone May Punish — John Locke argues that before any government there is already a law that every person may enforce, and that it breaks down because each person judges his own case, the more so once money lets people…
  4. Rousseau: Society Painted as Nature — Rousseau agrees that the people around him are proud and envious, but denies that this shows what human beings are by nature, and so asks what the state was really built to cure.
  5. The Case Against the State — Kropotkin and Stirner deny that anyone owes the state obedience, and their case runs into a hard choice: whoever restrains the strong starts to build a state again.
  6. The Contract Nobody Signed — Locke rests obedience on consent, given aloud or quietly; Hume answers that almost no one gave it, and that a promise to obey would be no stronger than obedience itself.
  7. Utility and the Innocent — Jeremy Bentham grounds law and punishment in the sum of happiness, and he answers the charge that the sum could convict an innocent man by counting it as a cost, not a ban.
  8. Fair Play and the Verdict — John Rawls argues that taking the benefits of a just scheme binds you to share its burdens, Robert Nozick answers that a benefit pressed on you creates no debt, and the last word is on who is bound…

Works read in this course

  • Leviathan — Hobbes's 1651 masterwork: the natural condition, the laws of nature, and the covenant that erects the sovereign
  • Two Treatises of Government — Locke's reply (1689): a moralized state of nature, the strange doctrine of punishment, consent and its limits
  • Discourse on the Origin of Inequality — Rousseau's 1755 conjectural history: natural pity, the fall into society, and the rich man's fraudulent contract
  • Of the Original Contract — Hume's 1748 essay: the refutation of tacit consent — the poor peasant and the ship
  • The Ego and Its Own — Stirner's 1844 refusal of every authority set above the individual — the anarchist seat at the table
  • Bentham, A Fragment on Government; Mill, Utilitarianism — the utilitarian justification of obedience, defended and broken open
  • Plato, Republic II (Glaucon) — the oldest contract picture — justice as a compact of the mutually vulnerable

Terms introduced

state of nature, sovereign, tacit consent, principle of utility, principle of fairness

Part of the Simposeum course library.