Who Should Rule?

Plato says ruling is a craft the crowd never learned; Aristotle, Machiavelli, Rousseau, Mill, Confucius and Mencius answer him, and Plato replies.

A course on the thought of Political Philosophy.

Course outline

  1. The Ship of State — Plato, who watched a democracy put his teacher to death, argues that ruling is a craft like navigation, so a crowd that picks whoever pleases it passes over the one who knows the way.
  2. The Feast of the Many — Aristotle answers Plato: we are political animals, many ordinary judges together can see more than one expert, and the steadiest city blends rich and poor around a strong middle.
  3. The Tumults of Rome — Machiavelli argues that the quarrels between Rome's people and its senate made Rome free, because the people, who want only not to be dominated, are the surest guard of liberty.
  4. The General Will — Rousseau argues that only law made by the whole people for the whole people is legitimate, that government is its hired servant, and that a citizen who loses a vote on the common good has learned he…
  5. The Tyranny of the Majority — John Stuart Mill warns that a people ruling itself can still oppress its own members, through law and through opinion and custom, and he draws one line against it: only harm to others warrants…
  6. Rule by Virtue — Confucius holds that a ruler governs by his own character, and Mencius adds that the people come first, so a ruler who misrules loses Heaven's mandate.
  7. The Verdict: What Survived the Ship — Plato's story of democracy sliding into tyranny is told once more, then tested against Aristotle's corrections and Annas's reading, to see which part of his warning still holds.

Works read in this course

  • Republic — Plato's masterwork: the ship of state, the craft of ruling, philosopher-kings — and democracy as the embroidered coat
  • Politics — Aristotle's reply (c. 330 BCE): man the political animal, the summation argument, the mixed constitution
  • Discourses on Livy — Machiavelli's republican testament (c. 1517): the tumults that kept Rome free, the people more prudent than a prince
  • The Social Contract — Rousseau (1762): the general will, the people as sovereign, the rulers as mere servants of the law
  • On Liberty and Considerations on Representative Government — Mill (1859, 1861): the schooled citizen, representation, and the tyranny of the majority
  • Analects — Confucius, via his students: the rule of virtue that commands like the Pole Star
  • Mengzi — Mencius (c. 300 BCE): the people the most important, the ruler the least — and Heaven's mandate forfeit by misrule

Terms introduced

guardians, general will, will of all, tyranny of the majority, Mandate of Heaven

Part of the Simposeum course library.