Liberty
Where society's power over a person must stop: Locke on conscience, Mill on harm and speech, then Rousseau, Nozick and Foucault answering.
A course on the thought of Political Philosophy.
Course outline
- The Care of Souls — Hiding in Holland in 1685, John Locke argued that a ruler's force can make people go to church but never make them believe, and then set limits on his own toleration.
- One Very Simple Principle — John Stuart Mill draws one line between conduct society may force and conduct it must leave alone, and then finds that the line keeps moving.
- The Liberty of Thought and Discussion — Mill argues that even an opinion we are sure is false must be free to be spoken, because silencing it claims we cannot err, an unchallenged truth goes dead, and most quarrels are between part-truths…
- Experiments in Living — Mill argues that a life chosen rather than copied from custom is how a person and a society grow, and his critics' charge that he exaggerated the danger does not answer him.
- The Open Door and the Prison Within — Rousseau argues that freedom means obeying a law we make together, so a citizen held to the general will is forced to be free, and the lesson sets this second idea of freedom beside Mill's.
- The Man Who Owns Himself — Robert Nozick argues that separate persons have rights no social good outweighs, that free exchanges upset any fixed pattern of holdings, and that taxing earnings to restore the pattern seizes hours…
- The Cell and the Verdict — Foucault describes a power that trains people by watching them; Mill had already feared that kind of moulding, and his principle of liberty survives the challenge, contested but standing.
Works read in this course
- On Liberty — Mill's 1859 manifesto of the free individual: the harm principle, free thought, and individuality
- A Letter Concerning Toleration — Locke (1689): the care of souls is not the magistrate's — liberty of conscience, the historical seed
- The Social Contract — Rousseau (1762): freedom as obedience to the general will — the citizen 'forced to be free'
- Anarchy, State, and Utopia — Nozick (1974): self-ownership, the entitlement theory, and the Wilt Chamberlain argument that liberty upsets patterns
- Discipline and Punish — Foucault (1975): the panopticon and the disciplinary production of the modern individual
- Considerations on Representative Government — Mill (1861): government as the school of citizenship — cited for the participation argument
Terms introduced
harm principle, self-regarding, dead dogma, experiments of living, forced to be free, self-ownership, discipline, panopticon
Part of the Simposeum course library.