Justice
Who should get what? Seven thinkers argue desert, labour, need, fairness, luck and liberty, each in his own words.
A course on the thought of Political Philosophy.
Course outline
- The Question of Social Justice — In a London workhouse yard after the crisis of 1866 we meet the question of who should get what, its three rival answers of desert, need and equality, and why they collide when each side claims a…
- Desert: Justice as Proportion to Merit — Aristotle argues that a just share matches merit, then settles the quarrel over which merit counts by asking what the thing being shared is for.
- Property: The Labour Theory and What We Own — John Locke argues that we come to own what we mix our labour with, within two limits that money loosens, and Robert Nozick asks why mixing should make anything ours at all.
- Exploitation: The Labour That Is Taken — Karl Marx argues that a worker paid the full value of his capacity to work still gives hours for nothing, because the wage hides the split, and he proposes that goods follow need instead.
- Justice as Fairness: The Modern Landmark — John Rawls asks which rules we would choose without knowing our place, and answers with two ranked principles: equal liberties first, then inequalities only when they help the worst off.
- Luck and Choice: Did Rawls Go Far Enough? — Ronald Dworkin wants each person's share to answer to their choices and not their luck, and tests a fair division with a shipwreck, an auction, an envy test and an imagined insurance market.
- The Objection from the Right — Robert Nozick argues that a holding is just if it came about justly, that free choices upset any pattern, and that taxing earnings is on a par with forced labour, and the lesson weighs that claim…
- The Objection from the Left, and the Verdict — G. A. Cohen argues that justice must reach the pay people choose to demand, John Rawls holds that it judges public rules, and the course's last question asks what your own first view costs.
Works read in this course
- A Theory of Justice — Rawls (1971, rev. 1999): the original position, the veil of ignorance, the two principles, the difference principle — the landmark of modern political philosophy
- Nicomachean Ethics — Aristotle: distributive justice as proportion to merit — the oldest theory of who deserves what
- Two Treatises of Government — Locke (1689): the labour theory of property — mixing one's labour with the world makes it one's own
- Critique of the Gotha Programme — Marx (1875): 'from each according to his ability, to each according to his needs' — the communist ideal beyond bourgeois right
- Anarchy, State, and Utopia — Nozick (1974): the entitlement theory and the libertarian objection — justice is historical, not patterned; liberty upsets the pattern
- A Matter of Principle / Sovereign Virtue — Dworkin: equality of resources — the auction, the envy test, brute luck vs option luck, the insurance scheme
- If You're an Egalitarian, How Come You're So Rich? / Rescuing Justice and Equality — Cohen: the egalitarian critique — the incentives argument lets the talented hold society to ransom; justice needs an ethos, not only institutions
Terms introduced
distributive justice, desert, need, veil of ignorance, difference principle, common asset, surplus value, brute luck, option luck
Part of the Simposeum course library.