Power & Revolution
Five thinkers on power: what politics is, what founding costs, why violence cannot make power, and what revolutions, inheritance and terror teach.
A course on the thought of Political Philosophy.
Course outline
- What Politics Is — Hannah Arendt separates labour, work and action, and argues that politics is action among equals, which fades when the household's needs take over public life.
- The Realm of Its Own, and the Founder — Machiavelli argues that politics has its own rules, so the founder of a state must learn to be able not to be good, and Hannah Arendt asks what that costs.
- Power and Violence — Hannah Arendt answers the old belief that power grows out of force: power is people acting together, and violence, a mere tool, can wreck it but never make it.
- Revolution and the Social Question — Marx reads the Paris Commune as proof that class struggle drives history, and Arendt answers that when misery floods a revolution, need crowds out the founding of freedom.
- The Conservative Answer — Edmund Burke answers the revolutionaries that rights are an inheritance held in trust, and that society is a partnership of the living, the dead and the unborn, a view Hannah Arendt later found…
- Totalitarianism and the Banality of Evil — Hannah Arendt explains total domination as a new kind of rule that makes people superfluous, and argues that Adolf Eichmann served it through thoughtlessness rather than monstrous motives.
- Power Everywhere, and What Politics Is For — Foucault shows power working through discipline, watching and ranking from everywhere instead of from a throne, and Arendt answers with the councils, where equals begin something new together.
Works read in this course
- The Human Condition — Arendt (1958): the vita activa — labor, work, action — plurality, natality, and the rise of the social
- On Violence — Arendt (1970): the severing of power from violence — power as acting in concert, violence as mere instrument
- On Revolution — Arendt (1963): liberation vs freedom; the American and French revolutions; the lost treasure of the councils
- The Origins of Totalitarianism / Eichmann in Jerusalem — Arendt (1951, 1963): totalitarianism as a novel form; the banality of evil
- The Prince / Discourses on Livy — Machiavelli: the political as its own realm, virtù, the founder who must learn 'not to be good'
- The Civil War in France / Capital — Marx: revolution, the expropriation of the expropriators, the social question at the centre of politics
- Reflections on the Revolution in France — Burke (1790): society as a partnership across generations; the danger of the wiped slate
- The History of Sexuality, Vol. I — Foucault (1976): power as productive and capillary, everywhere; biopower; where there is power, there is resistance
Terms introduced
work, action, natality, the social, power, violence, freedom, totalitarianism, virtù
Part of the Simposeum course library.