Power & Revolution

Five thinkers on power: what politics is, what founding costs, why violence cannot make power, and what revolutions, inheritance and terror teach.

A course on the thought of Political Philosophy.

Course outline

  1. What Politics Is — Hannah Arendt separates labour, work and action, and argues that politics is action among equals, which fades when the household's needs take over public life.
  2. The Realm of Its Own, and the Founder — Machiavelli argues that politics has its own rules, so the founder of a state must learn to be able not to be good, and Hannah Arendt asks what that costs.
  3. Power and Violence — Hannah Arendt answers the old belief that power grows out of force: power is people acting together, and violence, a mere tool, can wreck it but never make it.
  4. Revolution and the Social Question — Marx reads the Paris Commune as proof that class struggle drives history, and Arendt answers that when misery floods a revolution, need crowds out the founding of freedom.
  5. The Conservative Answer — Edmund Burke answers the revolutionaries that rights are an inheritance held in trust, and that society is a partnership of the living, the dead and the unborn, a view Hannah Arendt later found…
  6. Totalitarianism and the Banality of Evil — Hannah Arendt explains total domination as a new kind of rule that makes people superfluous, and argues that Adolf Eichmann served it through thoughtlessness rather than monstrous motives.
  7. Power Everywhere, and What Politics Is For — Foucault shows power working through discipline, watching and ranking from everywhere instead of from a throne, and Arendt answers with the councils, where equals begin something new together.

Works read in this course

  • The Human Condition — Arendt (1958): the vita activa — labor, work, action — plurality, natality, and the rise of the social
  • On Violence — Arendt (1970): the severing of power from violence — power as acting in concert, violence as mere instrument
  • On Revolution — Arendt (1963): liberation vs freedom; the American and French revolutions; the lost treasure of the councils
  • The Origins of Totalitarianism / Eichmann in Jerusalem — Arendt (1951, 1963): totalitarianism as a novel form; the banality of evil
  • The Prince / Discourses on Livy — Machiavelli: the political as its own realm, virtù, the founder who must learn 'not to be good'
  • The Civil War in France / Capital — Marx: revolution, the expropriation of the expropriators, the social question at the centre of politics
  • Reflections on the Revolution in France — Burke (1790): society as a partnership across generations; the danger of the wiped slate
  • The History of Sexuality, Vol. I — Foucault (1976): power as productive and capillary, everywhere; biopower; where there is power, there is resistance

Terms introduced

work, action, natality, the social, power, violence, freedom, totalitarianism, virtù

Part of the Simposeum course library.