Alchemy
How George Soros built a way of working on Karl Popper's 'we cannot know', from a 1970 note to 1987.
A course on the thought of George Soros.
Philosophy · Finance
Course outline
- The Note — A dated 1970 report on mortgage trusts shows George Soros wrote his idea down before he made money on it, but it cannot show that the idea, rather than instinct, earned it.
- Invest First, Investigate Later — Soros took from Karl Popper the idea that no guess can be proved right, only proved wrong, and turned it into a habit of acting first so that the market could show him his mistakes quickly.
- Being Wrong Fast — Soros said his edge was not foresight but speed: he found his own mistakes sooner than others and treated even his body's discomfort as news about a bet.
- The One Place a Prediction Costs Something — Soros parts from Karl Popper on one point: in human affairs people's beliefs change the things they are beliefs about, and a market is where a wrong belief costs money.
- The Experiment That Publishes Its Own Failure — From 1985 to 1986 Soros kept a dated public diary of his forecasts and trades, mistakes left in, and concluded that it showed he could correct himself, not that he could predict.
- 1957 — Popper described a forecast that helps cause what it forecasts and used it against predicting history; Soros made the same mechanism the engine of markets, and the record of their contact is too thin…
Works read in this course
- The Alchemy of Finance — Soros's 1987 book setting out reflexivity and containing the real-time experiment that tests it.
- The Poverty of Historicism — Popper's 1957 argument against the claim that history has laws permitting prediction — and the book in which the Oedipus effect is named.
- The Open Society and Its Enemies — Popper's 1945 attack on the intellectual sources of totalitarianism; the book that started all of this in Course II.
Built from
This course was built from 4 books.
- Michael T. Kaufman, Soros: The Life and Times of a Messianic Billionaire
- George Soros, The Alchemy of Finance
- Sebastian Mallaby, More Money Than God
- Karl Popper, The Poverty of Historicism
Terms introduced
reflexivity, fallibility, the unity of method, the real-time experiment, the Oedipus effect
Part of the Simposeum course library.