The Ladder

How 1940s American agitators worked their audiences: a grievance never named, an insult, a hollow enemy, an empty promise, a self-portrait.

A course on the thought of Leo Löwenthal.

Rhetoric

Course outline

  1. The Missing Grievance — Two researchers go looking for what the American agitators of the 1940s were complaining about, and their failure to find it becomes the study's first result.
  2. Recruitment by Insult — Why the American agitator of the 1940s called his own followers fools, never let them stop being fools, and why they thanked him for it.
  3. An Enemy With Nothing Behind It — Löwenthal and Guterman show how the agitator builds an enemy who wants nothing, is stripped of humanity in three moves, and is drawn both mighty and weak, so that the only remedy left is to hunt him…
  4. A Home With No Address — The agitator promised his followers no better society, only a purge dressed up as housecleaning, a place in a majority defined by its enemy, and the right to be violent on someone else's behalf.
  5. One of You, and Above You — The agitator paints himself twice over, as a hunted and penniless martyr and as a tireless leader with bodyguards and secrets, and each picture ties his listeners more tightly to him.
  6. What the Listener Heard — The book finishes by refusing two comforts: it will not call the agitators harmless because they were weak, and it will not claim to know what their listeners took away, because it read texts and…

Works read in this course

  • Prophets of Deceit: A Study of the Techniques of the American Agitator — Leo Löwenthal and Norbert Guterman's 1949 analysis of American agitation, built entirely from the agitators' own speeches and periodicals, and published as a volume of Studies in Prejudice.
  • The Broom — Leon de Aryan's weekly newspaper, San Diego, one of the fourteen sources listed in Löwenthal's Appendix II; San Diego State University holds the run and it is public domain.

Terms introduced

malaise, Studies in Prejudice

Part of the Simposeum course library.