The Verdict

A verdict on the discoverers of the unconscious: legend against record, Charcot's hysteria, suggestion, creative illness, Loftus's false memories, and what survives.

A course on the thought of The Unconscious.

Psychology

Course outline

  1. The Legend and the Record — A famous story about Freud's 1886 lecture on male hysteria, checked against the minutes of the meeting, shows why the record comes before any verdict on these discoverers.
  2. Charcot Measures Hysteria — Charcot treats hysteria as a real disease with fixed, measurable signs, and uses a thermometer to argue that fits which look like epilepsy are something else.
  3. Suggestion in the Ward — Charcot's patients went through his regular stages, but they had learned them from the doctors studying them, so his theory kept producing its own evidence.
  4. Discoveries Born of Illness — Ellenberger traces Freud's and Jung's theories to their own breakdowns, and Elizabeth Loftus shows why a truth felt from inside is not yet a truth proved.
  5. Planted Memories — Elizabeth Loftus shows that a question can slip a detail into a memory and that a suggestion can plant a whole false event, the same loop the old hypnotists ran, now inside a therapy room.
  6. What Survives — Loftus's measured memory and the therapist's lived realities meet, and Ellenberger keeps both as legitimate ways of knowing the mind.

Works read in this course

  • Lectures on the Diseases of the Nervous System — Charcot's Salpêtrière lectures (Sigerson trans.): hysteria as a lawful clinical entity, hypnosis as method
  • The Major Symptoms of Hysteria — Janet's 1907 Harvard lectures: dissociation, psychological automatism, the subconscious fixed idea
  • Psychological Healing — Janet's 1925 history + system of the psychotherapies: the cathartic cure and its priority
  • Selected Papers on Hysteria — Freud (Brill trans.): the early cases, from Charcot and Breuer to repression
  • The Interpretation of Dreams — Freud (Brill 1913): the dream as the royal road, the dynamic unconscious systematized
  • The Neurotic Constitution — Adler's 1912 system: organ inferiority, compensation, the guiding fiction
  • Analytical Psychology / Collected Papers on Analytical Psychology — Jung (1916): the complex, the word-association evidence, the collective unconscious
  • (secondary, authoring-only) Ellenberger, The Discovery of the Unconscious (1970) — the scholarly history this course is built on — not ingested, not quoted

Terms introduced

hysteria, repression

Part of the Simposeum course library.