The Verdict
A verdict on the discoverers of the unconscious: legend against record, Charcot's hysteria, suggestion, creative illness, Loftus's false memories, and what survives.
A course on the thought of The Unconscious.
Psychology
Course outline
- The Legend and the Record — A famous story about Freud's 1886 lecture on male hysteria, checked against the minutes of the meeting, shows why the record comes before any verdict on these discoverers.
- Charcot Measures Hysteria — Charcot treats hysteria as a real disease with fixed, measurable signs, and uses a thermometer to argue that fits which look like epilepsy are something else.
- Suggestion in the Ward — Charcot's patients went through his regular stages, but they had learned them from the doctors studying them, so his theory kept producing its own evidence.
- Discoveries Born of Illness — Ellenberger traces Freud's and Jung's theories to their own breakdowns, and Elizabeth Loftus shows why a truth felt from inside is not yet a truth proved.
- Planted Memories — Elizabeth Loftus shows that a question can slip a detail into a memory and that a suggestion can plant a whole false event, the same loop the old hypnotists ran, now inside a therapy room.
- What Survives — Loftus's measured memory and the therapist's lived realities meet, and Ellenberger keeps both as legitimate ways of knowing the mind.
Works read in this course
- Lectures on the Diseases of the Nervous System — Charcot's Salpêtrière lectures (Sigerson trans.): hysteria as a lawful clinical entity, hypnosis as method
- The Major Symptoms of Hysteria — Janet's 1907 Harvard lectures: dissociation, psychological automatism, the subconscious fixed idea
- Psychological Healing — Janet's 1925 history + system of the psychotherapies: the cathartic cure and its priority
- Selected Papers on Hysteria — Freud (Brill trans.): the early cases, from Charcot and Breuer to repression
- The Interpretation of Dreams — Freud (Brill 1913): the dream as the royal road, the dynamic unconscious systematized
- The Neurotic Constitution — Adler's 1912 system: organ inferiority, compensation, the guiding fiction
- Analytical Psychology / Collected Papers on Analytical Psychology — Jung (1916): the complex, the word-association evidence, the collective unconscious
- (secondary, authoring-only) Ellenberger, The Discovery of the Unconscious (1970) — the scholarly history this course is built on — not ingested, not quoted
Terms introduced
hysteria, repression
Part of the Simposeum course library.