Competition Is for Losers

René Girard on borrowed desire and the scapegoat, and what Peter Thiel built on it: competition, stagnation, politics after September 11.

A course on the thought of Peter Thiel.

Philosophy · Technology

Course outline

  1. The Question — Peter Thiel's favourite interview question asks for an important truth few people share, and it rests on his belief that such truths are still waiting to be found.
  2. The Borrowed Want — René Girard argues that we want what a model wants: a distant model is copied openly, and a model close at hand becomes a rival.
  3. The Victim Who Makes Peace — René Girard explains how rivals who copy each other end up united against one victim, and why the crowd then worships the person it destroyed.
  4. The Unmasking — Girard reads the story of Joseph and the Gospels as the scapegoat story told from the side of the innocent victim, and argues that once it is told, the old way of making peace through a guilty victim…
  5. Escape the Race — Peter Thiel argues in *Zero to One* that competition wipes out profit and makes rivals copies of each other, that René Girard's account of rivalry explains why, and that the way out is to find a…
  6. The Stalled Future — Peter Thiel sorts attitudes to the future by two questions, better or worse and definite or indefinite, and argues that outside computers progress stalled around 1970.
  7. The Straussian Moment — After September 11, Peter Thiel asked why modern politics cannot explain violence, and he tested the replies of Locke, Schmitt and Strauss against that question.

Works read in this course

  • Faust — Goethe's play, from which Thiel quotes the lines Faust speaks to Wagner, that mankind has always crucified and burned those who revealed what they knew to the crowd, and uses them to argue that a secret should be shared only with fellow conspirators.
  • The Lord of the Rings — Tolkien's tale, from which Thiel takes the verse about a new road or a secret gate as an emblem of hidden paths still waiting to be found.
  • Deceit, Desire, and the Novel — Girard's first book argues, through the great novelists, that desire is copied from a model rather than born in the self; Thiel takes from it the idea of mimetic desire on which his later thinking rests.
  • Violence and the Sacred — Girard's 1972 book arguing that sacrifice exists to channel a community's internal violence onto a substitute victim, and that myths like Oedipus hide a collective scapegoating; Thiel takes from it the scapegoat mechanism, in which the war of all against all ends as a war of all against one.
  • Things Hidden since the Foundation of the World — A long conversation with two psychiatrists in which Girard sets out the founding murder and reads the Gospels as its revelation; Thiel takes from it the claim that the hidden violence behind culture has been exposed.
  • I See Satan Fall like Lightning — Girard's late book reading the stoning at Ephesus and the Gospel story of the woman taken in adultery as two opposite answers to the first stone, and arguing that peoples deify their victims; Thiel takes from it the account of how the single-victim mechanism generates gods.
  • I See Satan Fall Like Lightning — Girard argues that the Bible, and the Gospels above all, take the side of the innocent victim and break the unanimity that myth depends on; Thiel takes from it the account of how the scapegoat lost its power and how the modern concern for victims can become a weapon.
  • Battling to the End — Girard's last book reads Clausewitz's escalation to extremes as what follows once scapegoats no longer work; Thiel takes from it the claim that the truth about the scapegoat comes out slowly and cannot be reversed, which gives the modern world an apocalyptic dimension.
  • Anna Karenina — Tolstoy's novel opens with the line that all happy families are alike and each unhappy family is unhappy in its own way; Thiel reverses it to argue that happy companies are all different because each has escaped competition.
  • Romeo and Juliet — Shakespeare's tragedy of two households "both alike in dignity" whose feud destroys their children; Thiel takes it as the model of rivals who fight because they are alike and forget why they started.
  • A Theory of Justice — Rawls's book holds that fair political reasoning must set aside knowledge of the world as it concretely exists; Thiel takes it as the leading example of indefinite optimism, a philosophy of fair process with no concrete picture of the future.
  • Zero to One — Thiel's 2014 book on startups, written with Blake Masters, whose chapter on luck and planning sets out the four attitudes to the future.

Built from

This course was built from 7 books.

  • Peter Thiel and Blake Masters, Zero to One (2014)
  • Peter Thiel, "The Straussian Moment", in Politics and Apocalypse, ed. Robert Hamerton-Kelly (2007)
  • Peter Thiel, "The Optimistic Thought Experiment" (2008), "The Education of a Libertarian" (2009), "The End of the Future" (2011)
  • René Girard, Deceit, Desire, and the Novel; Violence and the Sacred; Things Hidden Since the Foundation of the World; I See Satan Fall Like Lightning; Battling to the End; Evolution and Conversion
  • Cynthia Haven, Evolution of Desire, A Life of René Girard (2018)
  • Max Chafkin, The Contrarian (2021)
  • Michael Steinberger, The Philosopher in the Valley (2025)

Terms introduced

mimetic desire, monopoly, definite optimism, the Straussian moment

Part of the Simposeum course library.