The Contrarian on Trial
Peter Thiel's ideas set against his record: a student paper, PayPal, Facebook, Palantir, Gawker and Trump, then his teacher Girard's warning.
A course on the thought of Peter Thiel.
Philosophy · Technology
Course outline
- The Paper and the Mob — In 1987 Peter Thiel founded a student paper to fight a campus campaign over a reading list, and his 1995 book read that fight as a community holding itself together by blaming a victim.
- The Rivals Who Merged — PayPal and Elon Musk's X.com spent a fortune copying each other until they merged, the kind of war Thiel later wrote a company should escape rather than win.
- The Dorm Room Bet — Thiel's loan to Facebook shows his rule that one bet can outweigh all the others, and Chafkin shows him handling that bet like a cautious lender.
- The Seeing Stones — Thiel turns his ideas into three institutions, a data company, a venture fund and a fellowship for dropouts, and each grows away from the pitch it was sold with.
- The Patient Plot — From a 2007 blog post to a Florida verdict, Thiel secretly paid for other people's lawsuits until Gawker could not survive, and called it deterrence where his critics called it revenge.
- The Least Contrarian Bet — Why Peter Thiel, almost alone among the big names of Silicon Valley, backed Donald Trump in 2016, and how his diagnosis of a stalled age led him to that vote.
- The Cure Left Unused — In his last books Girard warns that rivalry now climbs without limit, and he counsels giving it up and refusing to accuse; Chafkin's record suggests Thiel mostly left that cure unused.
Works read in this course
- The Tempest — Shakespeare's play, in which the servant Caliban sings of freedom while trading his old master for a drunken butler he worships as a god; Thiel and Sacks take from it the warning that a crowd can mistake a new obedience for liberation.
- Atlas Shrugged — A novel by Ayn Rand (1957) that PayPal's early staff read as close to required, alongside Cryptonomicon; Thiel takes from it, on Chafkin's account, part of the libertarian ethos he imposed on the office.
- The Lord of the Rings — Tolkien's novel, whose seeing stones let their holders watch far-off events and are used chiefly by the villain to spy; Thiel took from it the name Palantir, and his company took from it its picture of itself as 'saving the Shire'.
- Zero to One — Thiel's 2014 book on startups, written with Blake Masters, in which he set down the rule that computers are 'complements for humans, not substitutes'.
- The Contrarian — Max Chafkin's 2021 unauthorized biography of Thiel.
- The Philosopher in the Valley — Michael Steinberger's 2025 book about Alex Karp and Palantir.
- Discourses on Livy — Machiavelli's commentary on the Roman historian Livy, whose chapter on conspiracies Holiday reads as teaching that some situations leave only one option, secret coordinated action against a powerful enemy, a lesson he says Thiel absorbed.
- Achever Clausewitz — Girard's last book, a conversation with Chantre published in English as Battling to the End, which reads Clausewitz's escalation to extremes as the shape of a modern world that has lost its sacrificial brakes; Thiel takes its apocalyptic frame but not its claim that no one can halt the escalation alone.
- Deceit, Desire, and the Novel — Girard's first book, which argues through the great novels that our desires are copied from models and attacks the Romantic lie of personal autonomy; Thiel takes the theory of copied desire while still urging readers to think for themselves.
Built from
This course was built from 8 books.
- Max Chafkin, The Contrarian (2021)
- Jimmy Soni, The Founders (2022)
- Ryan Holiday, Conspiracy (2018)
- Michael Steinberger, The Philosopher in the Valley (2025)
- David Sacks and Peter Thiel, The Diversity Myth (1995)
- Peter Thiel and Blake Masters, Zero to One (2014)
- René Girard, Evolution and Conversion; Battling to the End
- Cynthia Haven, Evolution of Desire, A Life of René Girard (2018)
Terms introduced
power law, the Thiel Fellowship
Part of the Simposeum course library.