Under Questioning
Quintilian's four ways to answer a charge, walked down one by one with the defence at Nuremberg, from the trial's own record.
A course on the thought of Nuremberg.
Rhetoric
Course outline
- What the Case Turns On — At Nuremberg in 1945 Robert Jackson chose the one question his case would turn on, and Quintilian explains what that choice is and how an advocate makes it.
- Inside the Defendants' Heads — Quintilian ranked denying the act as the strongest defence, but at Nuremberg the defendants' own papers closed that door, so their denials moved inward to what each man knew.
- Hanged for Words, Acquitted for Words — Two men at Nuremberg admitted their words and fought over what to call them, and the judgment named one incitement and the other a conduit for orders.
- The Most Honourable Defence — On the third rung of defence the accused admits the act and its name, then argues it was right or that it belongs to whoever gave the order, and at Nuremberg the judges refused to let an order carry…
- The Last and Only Hope of Safety — The fourth defence says the court has no right to try the case. Quintilian held that such a plea hides another question, and at Nuremberg that question was whether the acts were crimes when they were…
- Jackson Against Göring — Two prosecutors question Göring at Nuremberg in March 1946: one asks wide questions that let him choose the ground, and one keeps him on a single point, which is Quintilian's rule put to work in a…
Works read in this course
- Institutio Oratoria — Quintilian's twelve-book training of an orator, finished around AD 95 after twenty years of teaching; Book III sets out the four points a dispute can rest on and Book V how to question a witness.
- De Inventione — Cicero's early handbook, the route by which the Greek doctrine of stasis reached the Latin world and then the modern one.
- Trial of the Major War Criminals — The official record of the International Military Tribunal — every word spoken in the courtroom between November 1945 and October 1946, printed in full.
Terms introduced
quality
Part of the Simposeum course library.