Wittgenstein: Late

Wittgenstein turns on his first book: meaning as use, rules as practice, the inner and the outer, and the hinges of certainty.

A course on the thought of Ludwig Wittgenstein.

Course outline

  1. The Turn Against the First Book — Wittgenstein comes back to philosophy in 1929, drops his first book's demand that every sentence hide one pure logical form, and turns to look at how words are actually used.
  2. Bewitched by Language — Why a single noun can send us hunting for something that is not there, and why the cure is to describe how we already use our words, not to discover a new fact.
  3. Slab! Meaning as Use — Through four words shouted on a building site, Wittgenstein shows that a word's meaning is its use in an activity, not an object it stands for.
  4. Games Without an Essence — Wittgenstein looks at games instead of theorising about them, finds a family resemblance in place of a common essence, and shows why a concept with blurred edges still does its work.
  5. Following a Rule — A pupil who goes on adding four after a thousand shows that no explanation can fix what a rule requires, and that following a rule is a practice we are trained into, where reasons finally run out.
  6. The Beetle in the Box — Wittgenstein shows why words for sensations cannot be private: a diarist who checks her sign 'S' only against her own impression has nothing to be right about, and the beetle in each person's box…
  7. A Lion, a Face, a Form of Life — Why a talking lion would stay a stranger, and why a glance, a gesture or a tone can still tell us plainly what another person feels.
  8. Hinges: Where Doubt Comes to an End — Moore answered the sceptic by insisting he knew he had hands; Wittgenstein shows instead that our doubts turn on certainties that are never tested, as a door turns on hinges that stay put.

Works read in this course

  • Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus — Wittgenstein's early masterwork in numbered propositions: the picture theory of meaning, the saying/showing distinction, the limits of language, and the closing silence — 'whereof one cannot speak, thereof one must be silent'.
  • Notebooks 1914-1916 — Wittgenstein's wartime notebooks recording the genesis of the Tractatus, including the origin of the picture theory.
  • Philosophical Investigations — Wittgenstein's later masterwork (published posthumously, 1953): meaning as use, language-games, family resemblance, rule-following, the private-language argument, and philosophy as therapy.
  • The Blue and Brown Books — Dictated lecture notes from the early 1930s — the transitional thinking, including the first 'language-games', between the Tractatus and the Investigations.
  • Philosophical Remarks — A transitional work from 1929-30, Wittgenstein's first sustained writing after returning to philosophy, moving beyond the Tractatus.
  • On Certainty — Wittgenstein's last writings (posthumous), on knowledge, doubt, and the 'hinge' propositions that stand fast and make doubt itself possible.
  • Culture and Value — A posthumous selection of Wittgenstein's personal remarks on art, religion, music, and culture, gathered from his notebooks.

Terms introduced

Lebensform

Part of the Simposeum course library.